Pregnant In Divorce But Judge Refuse To Punish Her, Gets 50 Percent Of Matrimonial House
A Harare woman who was pregnant during her divorce trial, after her husband accused her of infidelity, has been given the first chance to keep their matrimonial home — but she must still pay her husband for his 50% share.
Rutendo Leah Mutumhe and Callistus Mufaro Mutumhe were married on 3 January 2007. No children were born from the marriage. She sued for divorce saying the marriage had irretrievably broken down. He accused her of having an extramarital affair.
During the trial before Justice Fatima Maxwell, it emerged that Rutendo had been retrenched on 31 January 2025, just a week before the trial, and that she was now pregnant. The pregnancy was not by her husband.
Her husband argued that she should not be given the house because she had moved on with her life and had caused him suffering due to infidelity.
Justice Maxwell dealt with the pregnancy directly in the judgment. The judge said the fact that the Plaintiff is now expecting a child should not be considered in her favor, as the pregnancy is not out of this marriage.
But the judge also refused to use the pregnancy to punish her on property. The court said the sharing of matrimonial property must be decided on contribution under Section 7 of the Matrimonial Causes Act, not on morality.
The judge found that both parties contributed equally to the acquisition of their matrimonial home, Stand **** Chadcombe Township, which is jointly owned. The house was bought through a mortgage facility from their employer, CBZ Bank Limited, where both worked.
The judge also found that Rutendo had not been shown to be incapable of buying out her husband. She told the court she had savings and was expecting a retrenchment lump sum package which would put her in a better position to buy him out.
On that basis, the court awarded Rutendo the first option to buy out Callistus’s 50% share of the Chadcombe property within 3 months of the date of receipt of the valuation report. If she fails, Callistus will be given the second option to buy out her share within a further 3 months. If both fail, the property will be sold to the best advantage and the net proceeds shared equally.
The court also dealt with the Toyota RAV4. Callistus argued the car was his alone because he took the car loan from his employer in his name, serviced it alone, and had sold a pre-marriage car to pay part of the price.
Rutendo argued they had agreed he would take the loan because there was no need for her to apply, and her salary was used for groceries, utilities and household needs so he could afford the loan.
Justice Maxwell agreed with her. The court held that both parties were using their earnings for the betterment of their marriage, and the vehicle must be treated as “theirs” and not “his”. The RAV4 must be valued and Callistus must pay Rutendo 50% of its value within three months, failing which it will be sold and the net proceeds shared equally.
The parties had already agreed at pre-trial that Callistus would pay Rutendo US$3,500 being her half share of the Tynwald property. The court confirmed that.
A decree of divorce was granted. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
What do you think — was the judge right not to punish her for the pregnancy? Drop your thoughts in the comments.

